I will update this post with final pictures when the time comes:
Tires: 5@ $973.02 - Includes mount balance and TPMS sensor switch over
Wheels: 5@ $913.65 - Includes centering ring and lugs
Total Price Installed : Estimated $1,886.67
It was a combination of advice, reading on the Outback forums, and reading reviews on that particular tire. Either way now that I have the 17" wheels I will have a little more freedom when I buy the next set of tires.
Nokians are quieter, retain traction and softness in very cold temperatures, and are better at siping water. Important since @Etumos lives in the Seattle area.
Geolandar A/T are great all around, especially for trail use. Still a great tire, but I think the Nokian are a superior tire for his uses.